It was no surprise to see a club pick up Luke Dunstan as an unrestricted free agent. But is Melbourne a good fit for him?
Career High SuperCoach Score: 141 vs West Coast (2014)
Career High SuperCoach Average: 93 (2019)
Career High AFLFantasy Score: 140 vs North Melbourne (2021)
Career High AFLFantasy Average: 100 (2020)
Embed from Getty ImagesImpact on New Club
At first glance, you might be thinking Luke Dunstan has made a mistake by joining Melbourne. Why pick the reigning premier when you could’ve been a shoe in to play 15-20 games annually at another side? While that is a valid point, the move to Melbourne, I believe, is astute for both.
For Dunstan, he moves into a club that’s clearly in contention for a premiership in 2022. Something that he likely wouldn’t be pushing for at some of these other clubs. Additionally, he adds immediate depth and squad pressure on their inside midfield stocks.
Melbourne won’t go ‘back to back because guys like Clayton Oliver, Mac Gawn, Christian Petracca and Jake Lever have stunning seasons again. Instead, it’ll be the retention of their high standards plus the growth of their ranked 16-25 players that’ll push them to the moon. Dunstan is an excellent addition to this team, and his hunger to break into the 22 will help support the existing high club standards and culture.
Impact on Old Club
Luke Dunstan was on the scrap heap at St Kilda. If he wasn’t moving clubs as an unrestricted free agent, he was going to be delisted. For the Saints to do this, they deliver the existing cattle of midfielders to cover him as a depth option.
In short, the impact was none. Either way, he was gone.
Fantasy Summary
There is no question that Luke Dunstan has a fantasy footy scoring pedigree. Even with just a tiny glance at last seasons 12 games, you can see it on full display. His top score of 140 against North Melbourne was one of four tons across the season. Additionally, Dunstan put on a further four scores between 90-99.
At his price point in salary cap formats, you can’t go there, even if injuries create opportunities. He won’t provide enough ‘fat on the bone’ to make money. Neither will he push his scoring to 105+, which he’d need to make him worth it.
No matter the depth of the draft league you are in, if you choose either Jack Viney or James Harmes, then Dunstan would be a highly desirable ‘handcuff’ option. Luke is the perfect cover for these players should either injury or suspension hit their inside midfield stocks.
